CD or Vinyl? Choosing a Jukebox for Your Home

Short version: if you own records, or want to start collecting, get the vinyl jukebox. It plays CDs as well, so you lose nothing. If your music lives on your phone and a shelf of CDs, the CD jukebox gives you the same 1950s look in a smaller cabinet.

Both sit in our jukeboxes range, and both are built around the same idea: a wooden cabinet with chrome trim and coloured lights on the outside, and modern connections on the inside. Below is what separates them, and what to check before one arrives at your door.

CD or vinyl jukebox at a glance

 

CD jukebox

Vinyl jukebox

Height x width x depth

105 x 57 x 30cm

127 x 64 x 38cm

Weight

Not listed

36.5kg

Records

No

Yes, 33, 45 and 78rpm

CDs

Audio CDs

CD, CD-R, CD-RW and MP3 CD

Radio

AM and FM, manual tuning

FM with auto search and 20 presets

Sound output

40 watts

40 + 40 watts

Power use

60W

100W

What both jukeboxes have in common

More than you might expect. Each one has a black wooden cabinet with 1950s-style chrome trim, and seven colour-changing LED bulbs in red, green, pink, yellow, white, aqua blue and royal blue. You can leave the lights on one colour or let them cycle through.

The connections match too. Both have Bluetooth for playing from a phone or tablet, a USB port, an SD/MMC card slot, a 3.5mm AUX input and an RCA line output if you want to run the sound into another system. There's an LCD display on each, and a remote that controls the lights and the sound, with batteries included.

Inside, both use the same speaker layout: two full-range speakers, two tweeters and a subwoofer. And both stand on four castors, so you can roll them into place rather than carry them.

So the real choice is about records and floor space, with volume a close third.

Why pick the vinyl jukebox

The turntable is the obvious reason. The vinyl jukebox plays at 33, 45 and 78rpm, so it covers LPs, singles and older shellac records, and there's a variable speed control as well. For anyone with a box of their parents' 45s in the loft, that's what makes a jukebox feel like a jukebox.

It doesn't give up the CD player to fit the turntable in. It reads CD, CD-R, CD-RW and MP3 CDs, so burned discs from years ago will still play. The FM radio searches for stations on its own and saves up to 20 presets, and the equaliser has Flat, Rock, Pop, Jazz and Classical settings. When it's on standby, the display shows a clock.

Sound output is listed as 40 + 40 watts, against 40 watts on the CD model, and it draws 100W from the mains rather than 60W. If you want it to carry across a bigger room or a garden-facing extension with the doors open, that's the one to go for.

The trade-off is size. At 127cm tall and 38cm deep it takes up more floor than the CD model, and at 36.5kg it's a two-person lift up a step or over a threshold, castors or not.

Why pick the CD jukebox

The CD jukebox is the better fit for a smaller room. At 105cm tall, 57cm wide and 30cm deep, it tucks against a wall without sticking out into the room, and it's short enough to sit under a window or beside a home bar.

It plays audio CDs, and it's the only one of the two with AM radio as well as FM, using a manual tuner and a wire aerial. You also get repeat and shuffle, programmable playback and a 2-band equaliser. As well as castors it has rubber feet, which help keep it still once it's in place.

If you stream most of your music anyway, this model makes a lot of sense. Pair your phone over Bluetooth, set the lights going and you've got the full retro look without needing to own a single record.

Measuring up and finding the right spot

Before ordering, measure the space you have in mind and check the height against anything above it, such as a shelf, a window sill or a sloping ceiling. Remember the depth too. A jukebox that's 38cm deep sticks out further than most people picture.

Both models run off a standard 220 to 240V UK mains socket, so plan for one nearby. Running an extension lead across a games room floor is asking for someone to trip over it.

Keep the jukebox out of direct sunlight and away from damp, so a cold garage or an outbuilding that gets condensation isn't a good home for it. For the vinyl model, a level floor matters. A turntable on a slope won't track records properly, and the castors make it easier to roll on a slight incline than you'd like.

Think about the doorways on the way in, too. Measure the narrowest point between the front door and the room, including any tight turn at the bottom of the stairs.

Making it the centre of a games room

A jukebox sets the mood for the whole room, so it's worth placing it where people gather rather than in a corner. Next to a home bar works well, or opposite a dartboard so it's in view while people play.

If you're building a full games room, our games room range includes dartboards, arcade machines, games tables and table tennis tables. Leave clear space in front of the jukebox for people to reach the controls, and keep it away from the throwing line of a dartboard.

One last tip. Use the remote to set the lights to a single warm colour for evenings, and save the colour-changing mode for parties. It's surprising how much difference that makes to how the room feels.


Shop jukeboxes at Bossy Cat

Delivery is free on all orders to UK mainland addresses and arrives in 3-5 working days, with no hidden fees. If you change your mind, you can return your order, but the return postage is paid by you.

Games room, Home bar, Jukeboxes

Frequently asked questions

  • Which is better, a CD jukebox or a vinyl jukebox?

    Go for the vinyl jukebox if you play records. It has a turntable for 33, 45 and 78rpm and still plays CD, CD-R, CD-RW and MP3 CDs. The CD jukebox suits a smaller room, at 105cm tall against 127cm for the vinyl model, and it's the one with AM radio as well as FM. Both have Bluetooth, USB and colour-changing LED lights.

  • What size is a home jukebox?

    Our CD jukebox measures 105cm high, 57cm wide and 30cm deep. The vinyl jukebox is bigger at 127cm high, 64cm wide and 38cm deep, and weighs 36.5kg. Measure the floor space, anything overhead such as a shelf or window sill, and the narrowest doorway on the route in. Depth catches people out, as 38cm sticks further into a room than you'd think.

  • Can a jukebox play music from my phone?

    Yes. Both the CD and vinyl jukeboxes have Bluetooth, so you can pair a phone or tablet and play your own playlists or a streaming app through the jukebox speakers. There's also a USB port, an SD/MMC card slot and a 3.5mm AUX input for a wired connection. Each comes with a remote that controls the sound and the lights.

  • Can a home jukebox play 78 records?

    The vinyl jukebox can. Its turntable runs at 33, 45 and 78rpm, with a variable speed control as well, so it covers LPs, singles and older records. The CD jukebox has no turntable and doesn't play records at all. For the vinyl model, stand it on a level floor so the turntable tracks properly.

  • How heavy is a jukebox, and can I move it?

    The vinyl jukebox weighs 36.5kg, so lifting it over a step or threshold is a two-person job. Once it's on a flat floor, it's easier, as both models stand on four castors and roll into place. The CD jukebox also has rubber feet to help keep it still. No weight is listed for the CD model.

  • How loud is a home jukebox?

    Loud enough for a games room or home bar. The vinyl jukebox is rated at 40 + 40 watts and the CD jukebox at 40 watts, and each has two full-range speakers, two tweeters and a subwoofer. For a large room, or sound carrying out through open doors, pick the vinyl model. The CD model has a 2-band equaliser, and the vinyl one has presets for Rock, Pop, Jazz and more.

  • Where should I put a jukebox at home?

    Somewhere near a UK mains socket, as both models run on 220 to 240V. Keep the jukebox out of direct sunlight and away from damp, so a cold garage or outbuilding with condensation is a poor choice. A spot next to a home bar or opposite a dartboard keeps it in view, but leave it clear of the dartboard's throwing line.

  • Can I buy a jukebox from Bossy Cat?

    Yes. We stock a CD jukebox and a vinyl record jukebox, both with wooden cabinets, chrome trim and seven colour-changing LED lights, in our jukeboxes range. Delivery is free on all orders to UK mainland addresses and arrives in 3-5 working days, with no hidden fees. If you change your mind, you can return your order, but the return postage is paid by you.